It’s been a few years since I became a full-time git user both at work and in the FLOSS projects I contribute to. I guess there’s no need to argue in favour of git at this point as it has become a sort of given on any sane software project—along with some other DVCS. I can’t really remember anymore how my life with Subversion was. Sad, I guess…
One of my favourite cultural shifts in software development brought by DVCS is the use of micro commits. JP has just blogged about it. Here are what I consider the most useful benefits of micro commits.
Tell a story. When you send one huge patch implementing a feature or fixing a bug, you’re completely hiding the incremental process through which you reached your final solution. On the other hand, a well written series of micro commits tell the reviewers the whole story of your code changes, step by step.
Discipline. If you want to tell a coherent story with your commits, you obviously need to organize them properly. Each commit should be a self-contained step towards the new feature or bug fix. Writing good patch series requires quite a bit of practice. It’s a very good exercise in terms of splitting a complex solution into a well-defined sequence of code changes—leading to more disciplined development practices.
Better code reviews. Because micro commits are, well, small, they are much easier to review because they do only one thing at a time. You get better code reviews as a consequence because the patches tend to contain no unrelated code changes.
Bisect and cherry-pick. Huge commits makes bisect and cherry-pick close to useless. And you don’t want that! Micro commits make it much easier to spot what caused a regression. Plus, they make it very easy to cherry-pick commits from one branch to another.
Git makes it utterly simple to move, split, squash, reorder, and remove commits providing the best ways to write good series of micro commits. It allows you to look like the perfect developer to the outside world by incrementally fixing your commits before submitting your patches for review. If you’re not micro-committing yet, you should.